The Lady With the Dog, By Anton Chekhov (1899)

 

The Lady With the Dog, By Anton Chekhov (1899)


Rating: 6/10

I could see a hero's journey in this short story. Gurov is becoming a hero. At first, I think he was not caring to Anna. Just because he loved him, he met her a lot in Yalta and when they met in the hotel, he just ate watermelon and said nothing. Gurov looked too clumsy and careless to me. When Anna went back home, Gurov went to her town, and started to wait her. It also looked careless, because he could have seen to Anna's husband. However, at the end of the story, Gurov and Anna started to think about their future. In this part, I though Gurov has grown a little and became a hero himself.
The reason I gave this short story 6 out of 10 is the ending is too opened. If the author had gave more information about their future, it would be easy to understand. But the structure was easy to understand, and it felt like a model of a love story to me. (169 words)

댓글

  1. Mr. Garrioch2022년 2월 27일 오후 6:25

    Good journal. The hero journey isn't as important to this story as "the question" Chekhov wants us to be left with - thus the ending that isn't an ending. What is acceptable in terms of happiness and love and right and wrong? Are they wrong? Is it a simple matter of being right or wrong or good or bad? No. That is the purpose of this story - not being easy to understand or answer.

    답글삭제

댓글 쓰기

이 블로그의 인기 게시물

A Manual for Cleaning Woman, by Lucia Berlin (2015)

 A Manual for Cleaning Woman, by Lucia Berlin (2015) Rating: 7/10 This story was not very interesting to me. Especially, the writing style did not satisfised me. Its writing style was the reminiscences of the narrator, by looking at the buses passing through her. This made the short story complexed. Short stories are too short to know about the sub characters, especially like these madames in theins story. Their description is not very long to know about them and how the narrator felt about them. If there were more specific descriptions, I think thw story would have been fun, because there are some funny episodes like finding the puzzle piece etc. And also, it was difficult for me to understand the theme of this story. The narrator thinks about her past, and watches the laundry room and the people riding motorcycles, and she cries. At first, the final ending developed too fast to understand. After listening about the discussion, I realized that she felt a lot of things, for example...
자세한 내용 보기

An Encounter, By James Joyce (1914)

  An Encounter, By James Joyce (1914)  Rating: 8/10 The most sympathized part was to get out of the routine. Living in KMLA in a strict routine, makes me deviate. In this short story, the narrator and his friend Mahony make a deviation and wander around Dublin. And then they see many people and places and meet a man. I think this man has bad thoughts. He is so conservative. Maybe it is because of the Irish religion. Catholic is one of the strict and conservative religions that I know, so this man may be influenced by the religion. I liked this quote from the story. "But real adventures, I reflected, do not happen to people who remain home: they must be sought abroad." I think this is like a hint of this full story. Because of this thought, the narrator could break away and see the society, meet a man that was an encounter. From this encounter, the narrator could feel better about his friend.  I think both <An Encounter> and <Araby> are similar as a growth stor...
자세한 내용 보기

The Sisters, By James Joyce (1914)

  The Sisters, By James Joyce (1914) Rating: 6.5/10 I wanted to talk about Flynn's confess. In the story, there is no answer of what Flynn confessed. However, through reading the story, there were hints. For example, old Cotter doesn't like the relationship between the narrator and Flynn. And, the sisters also talk about the confess. What I think is that Flynn did something wrong to the narrator, so he comes out in the narrator's dream and keeps it reminded.  The reason I rated this story 6.5 is I read this three times but it is stil difficult for me to understand. I can't know what the death of Flynn symbols. And also I don't know a lot of the Irish culture so it makes me difficult too. (119 words)
자세한 내용 보기